skip to Main Content

Star quarterback murdered cheerleader & shoots mom

Martice shot Kaylie five times/Crime Corner

Quarterback kills cheerleader.

Blog King, Mass Appeal

KENOSHA — “If I can’t have you, no one can.” Crime Corner released the murder documentary of 18-year-old Martice Fuller who was thrown in the slammer after he deleted his ex-girlfriend, 15-year-old Kaylie Juga, because she dumped his ass. Martice also tried to kill Kaylie’s mother, Stephanie Juga. The femicide transpired on May 9, 2019 at Kaylie’s residence in Kenosha, Wisconsin. Martice was the starting quarterback at Bradford High School. Kaylie was a varsity cheerleader. They appeared to be a match made in heaven. But, all hell broke loose when Kaylie — a victim of domestic violence — told Martice she was sick and tired of being his punching bag and she wanted out of the relationship. Rather than respect her wishes, Martice resorted to stalking and harassment. He was also physically abusive. A pissed-off Stephanie contacted the school and had Martice expelled and removed from the football team. His college scholarship offers were also retracted.

That proved to be the straw that broke the camel’s back.

On the day of the murder, Martice snuck in through the garage while Kaylie and Stephanie were preparing to go on a camping trip. He went upstairs, pulled out a gun and opened fire — striking Kaylie 5 times. She died at the scene. When mom jumped in to protect her daughter, Martice shot her too — leaving her critically injured. The mulatto signal-caller fled the scene and gave the murder weapon to a family member, who had the gun disposed.

Martice was eventually arrested, charged and convicted of murder, attempted murder and burglary.

It only took the jury 3 hours to reach a verdict.

Martice was sentenced to life in prison without the possibility of parole.

“You are a very dangerous and damaged human being,” Kenosha County Judge Mary Kay Wagner told Martice.

“You seem to have no ethos, no regret, no sorrow, no empathy. I don’t have any ability to trust that you will never commit these acts again.”

Realizing he’ll never step foot on the gridiron again, Martice cried for the first time during the 6-day trial.

While fighting through tears, Stephanie recounted all of the milestones that were purloined from her daughter.

“She was always by my side, and my biggest cheerleader, and now I’m lost,” Stephanie bemoaned.

“I feel so lost without her. We don’t get to see her graduate high school… We don’t get to see her go to college, or get married, or adopt children like she wanted to.”

Social media reaction was unforgiving.

One commenter wrote, “Shouldn’t be allowed to date at 15. Blame the momma.”

Another viewer added, “Reminds me of my first love at 18. First , he was very jealous. Then, he was verbally abusive. After 4 years, he tried putting his hands on me. I fought back lol. After the 3rd or 4th time, I said nope, I don’t respect you. Bye!!! Thank god I never kept his child too. Sorry, but not!!! He also threatened me to not keep it. Didn’t have to ask me twice. Anyways, he turned out to be a con man and was in and out of jail. [He’s] probably dead now 🤷🏼‍♀️ and looks like this guy, mixed black and white. Never dating a black man again!!!”

Should girls be allowed to date as teenagers?

Is mom equally culpable for Kaylie’s demise?

Watch the explosive documentary, which includes courtroom footage.

Share your thoughts.

This Post Has 38 Comments

  1. This is why I didn’t allow my daughter to date until she was a senior and she is now 19 still monitoring I don’t trust men at all or boys they have issues

  2. You gotta protect your home now a days!!! Where were his parents? Poor momma 😢

  3. judging by the tiktok in the beginning, she had to have done something to make that guy snap

  4. So you mean this girl would be alive if her parents didn’t allow her to have relationship problems at 15yrs old… oh ok 👍

  5. Lmao just seeing her trying to act black I knew this wouldn’t end well this happens every single time with this type of girl 😅

  6. Feel so bad for her mom, she’s had to deal with walking in on the crime scene and then being shot herself then going on with life without her daughter smh

  7. @Nicky Alii: Dating at 15 is not the problem. I know a lot of childhood sweethearts that are still married today. This happens to adult women too, and more often. These young and older men need relationship counseling prior to ever being in any relationship. This is sad.

  8. I’m sorry, but why is it always interracial couples?
    I don’t get it. I’ve seen too many of these cases lately. It’s hard not to notice a pattern.

  9. Exactly why young people shouldn’t be dating. He basically got pussy🐱whipped and didn’t know how to control his emotions. I wanna know where he got that gun. And why it was so easily accessible.

  10. Life without parole and he wasn’t even 20 yrs old yet. Too many of y’all crashing out early and often. It’s insane.

  11. Nah don’t cry now buddy sit in there for life and think about ur actions. 18 playing football but u wanna crash out when u had ur whole life ahead of u. Condolences to the family.

  12. Boy y r u crying!!! Wut chu expect fool..now u fina be washing big joes clothes and bringing him his food among other things

  13. The judge said it right “you have no ethos” she was so profound with her speech and gave the right sentence! This young man is just pure evil!!

  14. Fuck this judge.. it ain’t for her to say he would never change. If he was white, she would’ve given him a chance at parole..

  15. His parents are to blame all the way. I don’t know what his upbringing was- good, bad or just not interested?! However they know he had problems and was out of control, and instead of getting him help, they kicked him out of the house and let him run wild.

  16. @Jo Anderson: I think the parents of this boy realized they had a psychopath in their home. I dare say they had tried all sorts of treatments, rules, punishments and consequences. But they would have added to his selfishness, psychotic narcissistic tendencies. Probably told to change or leave…. Sometimes is not about nurture it’s just there nature, a chemical imbalance in their brains…. Neuron’s that don’t work in the empathy region of the brain. Hence why the judge hasn’t given parole. Nothing would or will make this person change.

  17. Letting your 15 year old daughter “date” like that is crazy!! He is basically living in your house with your daughter. Let’s not look past that part. It’s a shame the mom lived and the daughter didn’t.

  18. The judge was kind of wrong.
    He is/was a child and it’s proven that our brains are not developed until age 25..

  19. Abusive and controlling relationships among teenagers are more common than you’d think. I know so many friends from high school, as well as me who went through this. Parents need to be hyperaware of who their teenagers choose to spend their time with. This case is beyond saddening. Prayers for her family and friends. RIP Kaylie.

  20. Penalty for such crimes should be much higher. Like an eye for an eye. Maybe then people would think twice before acting.

  21. So he got life! Finally a case where actual justice was served. I’ve seen so many lately where the sentence is a complete insult to the crime committed.

  22. this case hit way close to home. my ex bf was physically and sexually abusive to me at 14-16 years old. we had a son which he is not allowed to see and sadly my court case was dropped against him. if there is any other young girls reading this, please know that they never change.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Back To Top